A stock or membership interest purchase leaves the target entity alive. Its unfiled returns, its unpaid payroll taxes, its broken S election and its limited loss carryforwards survive the closing and become yours. No statute hands them back to the seller. Only the purchase agreement does that, and only if it is drafted to.
What actually transfers when you buy stock instead of assets?
A stock or unit purchase transfers ownership of the entity, not its assets. The target keeps its EIN, its filing history, its elections, its licenses and every liability it already incurred, including taxes it never reported. An asset purchase leaves most of that behind, subject to state successor liability rules.
Buyers take stock deals anyway, to keep a license or a contract that will not assign. The alternative is no clean escape: many states impose successor liability on an asset buyer for the seller’s unpaid sales and withholding taxes absent a clearance certificate.
There is a middle path for S corporations, with a trap in it. A section 338(h)(10) election treats a qualifying stock purchase as a deemed asset sale and steps up your basis, but only where the buyer is a corporation taking at least eighty percent of the stock within twelve months. An individual, or an LLC that is disregarded or taxed as a partnership, cannot make one. Section 336(e) reaches a similar result without a corporate buyer, but the target and its shareholders make that election, not you, so you get it only by contract. Either route can trigger corporate-level built-in gains tax if the target converted from C status within the recognition period.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 338(d)(3), 338(h)(10); 26 U.S.C. 336(e); 26 U.S.C. 1374; Treas. Reg. 1.336-2(h).
Who owes the target’s unpaid payroll taxes after closing?
The entity owes them, and after a stock purchase the entity is yours. Income tax and the employee share of FICA withheld from paychecks are held in trust for the United States. If the target withheld and did not remit, the liability stays with the entity and a federal tax lien can attach to all it owns.
The lien arises on assessment, after notice and demand, and a security interest perfected before the IRS files its notice of lien generally outranks it. That is cold comfort. Your loan documents will treat a filed lien as a default, and the IRS can levy on cash and receivables.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 7501; 26 U.S.C. 6321, 6322; 26 U.S.C. 6323(a).
There is a second, personal layer. A responsible person who willfully fails to pay over trust-fund taxes owes a penalty equal to the unpaid amount, and willful means knowing they are unpaid and still paying other creditors. The rule has a limit: for money withheld and spent before you arrived, Slodov holds that a successor is not liable merely for using after-acquired funds to pay others, unless funds on hand at your accession trace to the withheld taxes. Past that, every trust-fund dollar coming due on your watch is yours.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 6672; Slodov v. United States, 436 U.S. 238 (1978); Finley v. United States, 123 F.3d 1342 (10th Cir. 1997) (en banc).
What if the target never registered for sales tax in states where it sells?
Sales tax nexus no longer requires physical presence. In South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. 162 (2018), the Supreme Court rejected the physical-presence rule, then vacated the judgment below and remanded rather than finally approving the statute. A target that shipped into threshold states for years without registering is carrying unreported liability.
Law: South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. 162 (2018).
The economics are ugly because the tax was never collected from the customer. The entity owes it out of its own margin, with penalties and interest, and you cannot invoice three years of customers after the fact. Thresholds differ by state and have moved since 2018, so test each year against that year’s rules.
State assessment periods generally run from the date a return is filed, so a company that never registered has nothing running in its favor and its exposure is measured in years of sales. Voluntary disclosure can shorten the lookback, but terms differ and acceptance is discretionary.
What happens if the seller paid its workers as 1099 contractors?
Worker classification is a tax determination, not a labeling choice. If people the target treated as contractors were employees under the common-law control test, the entity owes back withholding, both shares of FICA, unemployment tax and penalties. In a stock purchase that liability sits in the entity you bought, and the same workers are still on site on Monday.
One diligence item decides most of these cases. Statutory safe-harbor relief for a good-faith misclassification requires, among other conditions, that the business filed the required information returns for those workers. Ask for the Form 1099-NEC file. If the target paid cash or issued no 1099s, the cheapest defense is gone, and the reduced rates in section 3509 do not reach intentional failures.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 3121(d); 26 U.S.C. 3509; Section 530, Revenue Act of 1978, Pub. L. No. 95-600 (note to 26 U.S.C. 3401).
A seller who says “everyone in this industry uses subs” has described a custom, not a defense. The safe harbor is statutory, and it has conditions.
What if the target’s S election was never valid or was silently terminated?
Filing Forms 1120-S for a decade does not prove an S election. The election can fail because a shareholder consent was never signed, because an ineligible shareholder held stock, or because a governing document gave shareholders non-identical rights to distributions. A failed election means the entity was a C corporation and owed entity-level tax.
A missing Form 2553 is a proof problem, not an automatic failure, so ask for the IRS acceptance letter. If the election was invalid, the corporation owed the back tax, not the shareholders, and the corporation is what you are buying.
There is a cure path, and it is discretionary. The Code lets the IRS treat an inadvertently invalid election or termination as if it had never failed, on conditions the IRS sets, and published procedures fix common defects without a private letter ruling. Separate relief covers late elections, generally sought within three years and seventy-five days of the intended effective date. None of it is automatic. Start before closing and make the seller’s cooperation a surviving covenant.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 1361, 1362, 1362(f); Treas. Reg. 1.1362-6(b)(3)(iii); Rev. Proc. 2022-19; Rev. Proc. 2013-30.
Do the target’s net operating losses come with the company?
Net operating losses sit at the entity level only in a C corporation. If the target is an S corporation or an LLC taxed as a partnership, those losses passed through to the old owners and never come with the company. Where C corporation losses survive a stock purchase, section 382 limits their use.
An ownership change occurs when five-percent shareholders increase their holdings by more than fifty percentage points over the testing period, so buying outright is one. The annual deduction is then capped at the value of the loss corporation times the long-term tax-exempt rate, and falls to zero if the business is not continued for two years. Post-2017 losses also offset only eighty percent of taxable income. Do not pay face value.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 382(b), (c), (g); 26 U.S.C. 172(a)(2), 172(b)(1)(A)(ii).
How far back can the IRS go on the target’s pre-closing returns?
Assessment is generally limited to three years after the return is filed or its due date, whichever is later. It runs six years where the taxpayer omits more than twenty-five percent of gross income, and never starts where no return was filed or the return was false or fraudulent. One clean audit year proves nothing.
Assessment is also not collection: once assessed, a tax is generally collectible for ten years from the entity you now own, and a signed consent extends assessment on the waiver’s terms.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 6501(a), (c)(1), (c)(3), (c)(4), (e); 26 U.S.C. 6502(a).
Note the asymmetry. Survival for the seller’s tax representation should match the exposure, not a tidy twelve months. A date pegged to the applicable limitation period, plus a short tail for your claim notice, reaches the years still open. If you cannot win that date, move the risk into funded security.
What contract machinery actually holds pre-closing tax risk?
Six provisions do the work in a stock purchase: a pre-closing tax indemnity, a straddle-period allocation, audit control, a covenant against amending pre-closing returns, a cooperation and records clause, and funded security. Representations alone hold nothing. A representation gives you a claim; funded security gives you something to claim against.
| Exposure | Term that holds it | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Unpaid pre-closing taxes | Special tax indemnity | Outside the cap and basket, recoverable from dollar one |
| The year that spans closing | Straddle allocation | Interim closing of the books; property taxes prorated by days |
| Pre-closing audit opened later | Contest provision | Seller controls only if it funds the defense and accepts responsibility; otherwise you control, with consent over settlements binding later years |
| Seller amending a return | No-amendment covenant | No amended return, late election or voluntary disclosure for a pre-closing period without your consent unless law requires it |
| Missing records | Cooperation and retention | Retention tied to the limitation period; access to the accountant and payroll files |
| A seller who has spent the money | Escrow, price cut or note set-off | Sized to the quantified exposure, with release mechanics drafted |
I size the escrow off the quantified exposure first, then negotiate the agreement around that number. Sizing runs the other way too often: a round percentage gets picked because it sounds like market, and bears no relation to the three states where the target never registered. An escrow releases only on joint instruction or the determination the agreement specifies, so draft the release mechanics, not just the figure.
Two cautions for a loan-financed deal. Set-off against a seller note costs nothing to fund, but SBA rules frequently require seller notes on standby, and standby terms can restrict set-off. Those requirements change with the operating procedure in force, so ask the lender in writing how set-off works against its standby form. Insurance for representation breaches is uncommon at this size, so plan on the escrow, a price cut and the note as your only collection sources.
A seller’s signature on an indemnity is worth what the seller is good for. The escrow is worth what is in it.
Stated as of October 2026, the SBA operating procedure for 7(a) lending is SOP 50 10 8.1, issued by SBA Notice 5000-880695 effective October 1, 2026, with technical updates under Notice 5000-882227, applying to applications issued a loan number on or after that date. The SOP is revised often and amended between revisions by notices, so confirm the version in force with your lender rather than treating any summary as permanent. SBA regulations require holders of at least a twenty percent ownership interest to guarantee the loan in most cases.
Law: 13 CFR 120.160(a); SBA SOP 50 10 8.1 (effective October 1, 2026).
What should you ask for this week, and what do you tell your lender?
Tax diligence in a stock purchase starts with government records, not the seller’s spreadsheets. Account transcripts show what the IRS believes was filed, assessed, paid and still owed. Books show what the seller believes. Where they disagree, the transcripts are what the IRS will act on, and the gap belongs in the escrow.
I read the entity’s account transcripts before I read the seller’s financial statements. Build the request list around these items:
- A signed Form 8821 or 2848 for the entity, so your advisor can pull account and return transcripts for every open year.
- Forms 941 for twelve quarters, Forms 940, W-2 and W-3, state withholding and unemployment filings, and deposit confirmations.
- The signed Form 2553, the IRS acceptance notice, shareholder consents, and any agreement that could create a second class of stock.
- Thirty-six months of revenue by ship-to state against each state’s thresholds for those years, plus registration and filing history.
- The complete Form 1099-NEC file, with agreements for anyone paid repeatedly or hourly.
- Conversion date, C corporation returns and asset basis schedules; loss carryforward schedules; prior ownership changes.
- Six years of IRS and state notices, installment agreements and lien releases, plus lien and UCC searches on the exact entity name and former names.
- Franchise tax, annual report and unclaimed property filings in every registered state.
Then quantify. Turn each gap into a dollar range with a named basis, add penalties and interest, and total it. That total is the escrow, price cut or set-off you ask for, and the explanation your lender needs: the holdback reserves against a liability sitting inside the borrower entity, and so inside the collateral.
Last, decide what you will not sign. A stock purchase with no special tax indemnity, no straddle convention, no audit control and no funded security is a purchase of someone else’s filing history on your own guaranty. If the seller refuses all four, an asset purchase into a new entity may be the better trade, if you clear the state successor rules on the way out.
Keep reading
The Seller’s LibraryDiligence will test whether your S election is validThe Buyer’s LibraryPrice the contractor roster before you inherit it.The Seller’s LibraryAn F reorganization lets you sell units, not S corp stock.
Have a lawyer read it before you sign.
A purchase is decided in a handful of documents you sign exactly once — the letter of intent, the note, the indemnity. There is a right time to have them read, and it is before the lender sets your closing date.

Before founding Prencipe International, Joe practiced at the top law firms in the world, including Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, Baker McKenzie, Morgan Lewis & Bockius, and served at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He has spent his career on high-stakes disputes and transactions for businesses that cannot afford to lose. He represents buyers acquiring SBA 7(a)-financed businesses -- reading the letter of intent before it is signed, and the purchase agreement while there is still room to change it.
LinkedIn →
