Industrial machine room with spoked pulley wheels, hanging chains, pressure gauges, valves and pipe railings beside a concret

The goodwill may belong to the owner, not the company.

Goodwill that lives in one person — a name, a license, a phone — is usually not company property unless a contract makes it so. Buy the equity and you buy what the company owns, not what the owner owns. The tax cases draw that line on the paperwork, and the same facts make the goodwill hard to transfer.

What does it mean to say the goodwill belongs to the owner and not the company?

Personal goodwill is earning power attached to an individual rather than an entity. It arises where customers buy because of one person’s reputation, license or relationships, and where no employment agreement and no covenant not to compete has committed those relationships to the company. That goodwill is the individual’s and does not reliably pass with the equity.

The mechanism is ownership by contract. A company owns the truck because it bought the truck. Its claim to a relationship is weaker, because a relationship is exercised rather than acquired, by someone free to exercise it elsewhere tomorrow. What converts it into a company asset is the covenant not to compete, or an employment agreement assigning the person’s working life to the company. Trade secret and loyalty duties reach some of that conduct, but are weaker.

Apply that to your deal. You sign for one hundred percent of the membership interests. At closing you own the entity, and the entity still holds the equipment, the receivables, the lease and the name, subject to the consents a change of control requires. The seller walks out holding what produced the revenue. You have bought an income statement that can walk.

Which cases draw the line, and what facts decided them?

Four Tax Court decisions and one Ninth Circuit disposition set out the operative facts, and the pattern is consistent. Where the owner had signed no employment agreement and no covenant not to compete, the goodwill was held personal. Where he had signed both, it belonged to the corporation, whatever the sale documents called it. Each turned on its own record.

DecisionWhat the owner had signed with the companyWhose goodwillThe fact that mattered
Martin Ice Cream Co. (1998)Nothing, at any timeThe shareholder’sSupermarket relationships and a distribution arrangement held personally
Norwalk (1998)Covenants not to compete had expired and were not replacedThe accountants’Free to compete, so the client list had no meaningful value to the corporation
H&M, Inc. (2012)No agreement tying the agent’s relationships to the corporationThe agent’sInsurance in that market ran on one agent’s personal standing
Bross Trucking, Inc. (2014)No employment agreement, no noncompete, for the owner or his sonsThe owner’sA damaged regulatory record left the corporation no goodwill to distribute
Howard (9th Cir. 2011)An employment agreement and a covenant not to compete with his own corporationThe corporation’sControl had been conveyed to the entity; the label in the sale documents did not move it back

Law: Martin Ice Cream Co. v. Commissioner, 110 T.C. 189 (1998); Norwalk v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1998-279; H&M, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2012-290; Bross Trucking, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2014-107; Howard v. United States, 448 F. App’x 752 (9th Cir. 2011) (unpublished, not binding precedent).

Norwalk states the rule in the form to carry into diligence: there is no salable goodwill where a corporation’s business depends on its key people, unless those people sign a covenant not to compete or another agreement making their client relationships corporate property. That court was deciding a tax question. You are deciding whether to wire money. You put the same question to the documents.

Howard is the case for buyers, because it shows the repair. The dentist lost his personal goodwill argument because his corporation had taken the paperwork seriously years earlier. The disposition binds nobody, but that paperwork is what you look for in the seller’s files, and what you want signed at closing.

The covenant not to compete is not a tidying-up document for the end of the signing list. It is the instrument that moves the asset.

How do I test whether I am buying a business or buying the seller?

Owner dependence is measurable before an offer is made, from documents a buyer can request in ordinary diligence. The tests run in order, from revenue concentration to transferability of the work. Each is answered with a document or a name, never an impression. Run all seven before the letter of intent fixes a price.

  • What share of revenue comes from customers who deal with the owner by name. Ask for revenue by customer for thirty-six months and mark each account personal or institutional. If it sits with accounts that call the owner’s cell phone, the business is the owner.
  • Whether there are written contracts, or only habit. Request every customer agreement and standing purchase order. Habit is not an asset. A twenty-year relationship terminable at will is still terminable at will.
  • Whether the owner personally holds a license the business depends on. Trades, health care, insurance and transport often run on a license issued to a human being. Read the board’s register and its rules on qualifying an entity, naming a replacement qualifier, and any transition after a sale.
  • Whether a second person can already perform the work. Name that person. Look at whether they sign off on jobs, quote prices, or appear on customer correspondence. A general manager who has never quoted a price is not a second person.
  • What each counterparty does on a change of ownership. Read the assignment and change-of-control clauses, including in an equity deal, where they are assumed not to bite and often do. Then ask whether that buyer re-bids when the invoice name changes.
  • What the owner has already told staff and customers. If he has spent two years telling the top accounts he will always be there, you inherit a promise you cannot keep.
  • Whose name is on everything. Check the trade name, domain, email addresses, proposals and any trademark registration, and confirm the record owner of each.

I ask for the revenue-by-customer schedule and the top ten customer agreements before I ask for the add-backs. The add-backs tell you what the number should be; the schedule tells you whether the number belongs to the company.

What will an SBA 7(a) loan let me do about owner dependence?

SBA 7(a) acquisition financing caps the seller’s post-closing role, so a long transition is not available as a fix. As of October 2026, under SOP 50 10 8.1, on an initial acquisition the seller may not remain an officer, director, stockholder or employee, and may consult for no more than twenty-four months in aggregate, extensions included.

That cap is the constraint first-time buyers do not see coming. The instinct, on finding an owner-dependent business, is to keep the owner: a three-year employment agreement, a seat on the board. None of that is available. The seller may advise, briefly, and then is gone.

Note what the number does over time. Under SOP 50 10 8, effective June 1, 2025, it was twelve months. The current version doubled it. The procedure is revised, and your lender applies the version in force when your loan receives its SBA loan number, not when you sign. Treat every SBA statement here as current only to that date, confirm the SOP, and ask the lender which version governs.

Program rules: SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, effective October 1, 2026 for applications receiving an SBA loan number on or after that date (SBA Information Notice 5000-880695; technical updates, SBA Information Notice 5000-882227), replacing SOP 50 10 8, effective June 1, 2025, which governs loans numbered on or before September 30, 2026. Change-of-ownership rules sit in Appendix 15.

Why can I not just pay for the transfer only if it actually happens?

Contingent pricing is not available on this financing. SBA change-of-ownership requirements call for a price fixed and determinable at closing, and an earn-out is treated as inconsistent with the complete change of ownership the program requires. That is the position under SOP 50 10 8.1 as of October 2026. Confirm the version in force when your loan number issues.

The consequence is sharp. In larger transactions a buyer bridges transfer risk with contingent consideration, paying for the relationships only if they survive. That tool does not come down to this size of deal. The risk goes into one fixed number at signing, into terms your lender accepts, or you decline.

What you want to do about owner dependencePosition under SBA 7(a) acquisition financing, stated as of October 2026What is left to you
Keep the seller for three years as an employee or officerNot available on an initial acquisition; the seller may not remain an officer, director, stockholder or employeeA consulting engagement inside the capped window, written to transfer relationships
Pay part of the price only if the top accounts stayNot available; the price must be fixed and determinable at closingA lower fixed price, agreed before you are emotionally committed
Let the seller roll a minority stakeNot an initial acquisition; Appendix 15 treats it as an owner buyout, with its own equity, ownership and guaranty requirements, including a guaranty from the selling owner who stays inAsk your lender early whether it writes that structure
Hold back cash against relationship lossLender dependent, and only if it does not operate as an earn-out; seller financing and standby terms are set by the SOPPut it to the lender before exclusivity

There is one more move, and the cases point straight at it. Buy the personal goodwill expressly. Have the owner sign, individually, a covenant not to compete and a non-solicitation covenant running to the company you are buying, for a term and territory the governing state will enforce. Permitted scope varies sharply by state statute and case law, so the governing law clause is not boilerplate. No covenant is self-executing: breach gives you a claim, and injunctive relief is discretionary. It puts a remedy on the outcome that hurts most, the seller opening across the street.

How the price is then allocated across asset classes carries tax consequences for both sides, and the allocation you want is not the one the seller wants. That is treated separately by Prencipe International.

When is an owner-dependent business worth buying anyway?

Owner dependence is a discount, not a disqualification. A business priced for the risk that its revenue walks out the door can be a sound purchase where the buyer can credibly do the owner’s job. The question is not whether the seller is impressive. It is whether the revenue-producing work is work you can do or hire.

This cuts against you. These businesses are cheap for a reason, and the discount is compensation for a risk you carry with a personal guaranty behind it, because owners at and above the SBA ownership threshold must guarantee the loan. Some buyers pay an institutional price for a personal business and learn in month four that the revenue was never theirs. Others refuse every strong founder and never buy anything.

The conditions that make the discount worth taking are concrete. You hold, or can obtain, any license the business runs on. You can do the selling, or a named second person already does. The customer need is recurring and practical rather than loyalty-driven. The top accounts are contracted. And the seller signs the covenant without a fight.

A business with a strong owner has processes the owner happens to run. A business that is the owner has an owner and a bank account. The difference is whether anything is written down.

What should I do before I send the offer?

Pricing owner-dependence risk starts with four documents and two conversations, all available before a letter of intent. The documents are the revenue-by-customer schedule, the customer agreements, the license register entry and the organizational chart. The conversations are with the lender about structure and with the seller about what he has already promised.

  • Request revenue by customer, monthly, for thirty-six months, and total the personal and institutional columns.
  • Read the term, termination and change-of-control clauses in the top ten customer agreements.
  • Check the licensing board’s register for whose name the license sits in, and its rules on qualifying an entity after a sale.
  • Name the second person who can do the revenue-producing work, and verify it from correspondence.
  • Ask the seller what he has told staff and customers about staying, and put the answer in the diligence record.
  • Ask your lender which version of the operating procedure will govern, how it treats the seller’s role after closing, and what it accepts on price and seller financing.
  • Instruct counsel to draft the covenant not to compete and the consulting agreement early. Those two documents are where transfer happens.

Then price it. If the personal column is small, you are buying a business and should pay for one. If it holds most of the revenue and you cannot do that work, the price comes down or you walk. There is no third answer, because the financing will not give you one.

Buying a business?

Have a lawyer read it before you sign.

A purchase is decided in a handful of documents you sign exactly once — the letter of intent, the note, the indemnity. There is a right time to have them read, and it is before the lender sets your closing date.

Book a consultationHow we work with buyers

Joe Prencipe, Managing Partner of Prencipe International
Written by
Joe Prencipe
Managing Partner, Prencipe International

Before founding Prencipe International, Joe practiced at the top law firms in the world, including Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, Baker McKenzie, Morgan Lewis & Bockius, and served at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He has spent his career on high-stakes disputes and transactions for businesses that cannot afford to lose. He represents buyers acquiring SBA 7(a)-financed businesses -- reading the letter of intent before it is signed, and the purchase agreement while there is still room to change it.

LinkedIn →

Share this:

You might also like

©2026 Prencipe International

PRENCIPEInternational
SBA 7(a) Buy-Side · Counsel for Buyers
★★★★★ 5.0 · 24 Google reviews
Book a consultation
PRENCIPEInternationalBook a consultation
©2026 Prencipe International
SBA 7(a) Buy-Side · Nationwide