Ornate cast-iron staircase with marble treads and decorative newel posts in the lobby of a historic public building

Making the other side pay for a frivolous claim.

New York does not shift your legal bills to the plaintiff simply because the case against you collapses. Fees move only three ways: by contract, by statute, or by court rule. The court rule is 22 NYCRR 130-1.1. It reaches conduct that is frivolous, not conduct that is merely weak, and it can reach the plaintiff’s lawyer personally.

If you win, does the plaintiff have to pay your attorney’s fees?

No. New York follows the American rule. Attorney’s fees are incidents of litigation, and a prevailing party may not collect them from the loser unless an award is authorized by agreement between the parties, by statute, or by court rule. Winning a commercial case, standing alone, recovers nothing for the defense.

Case: Hooper Assoc. v AGS Computers, 74 NY2d 487, 491 (1989).

So the first question is not whether the claim was outrageous. It is which of the three doors is open. Contract: read the indemnification and prevailing-party clauses in the instrument the plaintiff is suing on, and read them narrowly, because the courts do. An indemnity clause is strictly construed and will not be read to cover fees in a suit between the parties themselves unless the language is unmistakably clear. Statute: a limited set of statutes shift fees in defined categories of cases. Court rule: that is Part 130.

Case: Hooper Assoc. v AGS Computers, 74 NY2d 487, 491-492 (1989).

If no door is open, the fee you pay to defend is simply the cost of being sued.

What does 22 NYCRR 130-1.1 actually allow a court to order?

22 NYCRR 130-1.1(a) permits a court, in its discretion and except where prohibited by law, to award costs in the form of reimbursement for actual expenses reasonably incurred and reasonable attorney’s fees resulting from frivolous conduct. In addition to or in lieu of costs, the court may impose financial sanctions on a party or attorney.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(a).

Two remedies sit in that subsection. Costs are compensatory: they reimburse the party who spent the money because of the frivolous conduct. Sanctions are punitive, and the money does not go to you. Under 22 NYCRR 130-1.3, a sanction paid by a party who is not an attorney goes to the clerk for transmittal to the Commissioner of Taxation and Finance; a sanction paid by an attorney goes to the Lawyers’ Fund for Client Protection.

Both remedies are discretionary. The verb in the rule is “may.” A court can find conduct frivolous and award nothing.

Part 130 does not apply everywhere. By its own terms the rule does not apply to town or village courts, to proceedings in a small claims part of any court, or to Family Court proceedings commenced under article 3, 7 or 8 of the Family Court Act. In Supreme Court, including the Commercial Division, it applies.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(a); 22 NYCRR 130-1.3.

What counts as frivolous conduct under 130-1.1(c)?

Subsection (c) defines frivolous conduct in three branches: conduct completely without merit in law that cannot be supported by a reasonable argument to extend, modify or reverse existing law; conduct undertaken primarily to delay or prolong the litigation, or to harass or maliciously injure another; and conduct asserting material factual statements that are false.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(c)(1)-(3).

Read the first branch slowly. It is not “without merit.” It is completely without merit in law, and incapable of support by a reasonable argument to extend, modify or reverse existing law. A claim that loses on summary judgment has not, by that fact alone, satisfied either half. That conjunction is where most sanctions motions fail.

The rule also closes a loophole. Frivolous conduct includes the making of a frivolous motion for costs or sanctions under the section itself.

Then come two factors a reader scanning the rule will miss. In determining whether conduct was frivolous, the court considers, among other issues, the circumstances under which the conduct took place, including the time available for investigating the legal or factual basis of the conduct, and whether the conduct was continued when its lack of legal or factual basis was apparent, should have been apparent, or was brought to the attention of counsel or the party. The list is not closed.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(c).

Those factors decide real motions. The first forgives a pleading drafted against a running limitations period on incomplete information. The second destroys that excuse, because it asks what happened after the problem was pointed out. I date the conduct before I characterize it, because the rule itself is written in time.

The question is rarely whether the complaint was wrong when filed. The question is what the plaintiff did on the day the complaint became indefensible.

This is why the letter matters. If you believe an allegation is baseless, say so in writing, identify it, attach the document that refutes it, and ask for withdrawal. The letter earns no award by itself; it builds the record for the second factor. A court applying Part 130 has imposed sanctions in a litigation characterized by vexatious and dilatory conduct concluding with a frivolous appeal, observing that sanctions are retributive in punishing past conduct and goal oriented in deterring future frivolous conduct by the parties and by the Bar at large.

Case: Levy v Carol Mgt. Corp., 260 AD2d 27, 34 (1st Dept 1999).

Can the plaintiff’s lawyer be made to pay personally?

Yes. Under 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(b), the court may award costs or impose sanctions against an attorney, against a party, or against both. Against an attorney, the award may run personally or against the firm, corporation, government agency, legal aid society or public defender’s office with which the attorney is associated and that appeared as attorney of record.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(b).

The signature on the pleading is not decoration. Under 22 NYCRR 130-1.1-a, every pleading, written motion and other paper served or filed must be signed, and the signature certifies that, to the best of the signer’s knowledge, information and belief, formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances, the presentation of the paper and the contentions in it are not frivolous as defined in 130-1.1(c).

So the lawyer who filed the complaint has certified a reasonable inquiry. When the document refuting the central allegation sat in that lawyer’s own client file, the certification is the problem, not just the pleading. Whether the court acts on it remains discretionary.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1-a(a)-(b).

How much is a Part 130 award actually worth?

Part 130 produces two separate numbers. Costs under 130-1.1(a) are measured by actual expenses reasonably incurred and reasonable attorney’s fees resulting from the frivolous conduct, and the rule sets no dollar cap on them. Sanctions are capped: under 22 NYCRR 130-1.2, sanctions may not exceed $10,000 for any single occurrence of frivolous conduct.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.2.

MechanismWhat it compensatesCeilingWho receives it
Costs under 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(a), discretionaryActual expenses reasonably incurred and reasonable fees resulting from the frivolous conductNo stated dollar capThe party or attorney who incurred the expense
Sanctions under 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(a), discretionaryNothing. A punitive assessment$10,000 per occurrence (130-1.2)Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, or the Lawyers’ Fund for Client Protection if paid by an attorney (130-1.3)
CPLR 8303-a, mandatory on a finding of frivolousnessCosts and fees for a frivolous claim, within the statute’s subject matter only$10,000The successful party
22 NYCRR 130-2.1, discretionaryAn attorney’s failure, without good cause, to appear at a scheduled appearanceSanctions and costs combined capped at $2,500 per failure to appear (130-2.2)Sanctions to the Lawyers’ Fund (130-2.3); costs to the party reimbursed

Note the consequence. The costs branch moves real money, and it is measured by what the frivolous conduct cost you, not by what the whole defense cost you. Build the fee application that way: tied to the specific motion, deposition and round of briefing the conduct caused.

A sanction is the court’s money. Costs are yours. Draft the motion so the court can give you both, and so it can give you the second one even if it declines the first.

Does CPLR 8303-a apply to your business case?

Usually not. CPLR 8303-a requires an award of costs and reasonable attorney’s fees not exceeding $10,000 to the successful party on a finding that a claim was frivolous, but only in actions to recover damages for personal injury, injury to property or wrongful death, and actions brought by the individual who committed a crime against the victim.

Law: CPLR 8303-a(a).

That subject-matter limit is the whole point. A breach of contract case, a dispute over the operating agreement, a claim on the guaranty, an account stated: none is an action for personal injury, injury to property or wrongful death, and the statute does not reach them. The edge is less clean on tort claims, because the General Construction Law defines injury to property broadly, as an actionable act lessening another’s estate other than a personal injury or a breach of contract. Check the pleaded causes of action before writing the statute off. In the ordinary commercial case, Part 130 is the live rule.

Two further features matter if your case does fall inside the statute. The award is mandatory once the court finds frivolousness, although the finding and the amount within the $10,000 cap remain for the court, and under subdivision (b) it may be assessed against the party, the attorney, or both. The subdivision (c) definition is narrower than Part 130’s, because each branch requires bad faith.

Law: CPLR 8303-a(b)-(c).

Is a weak claim a frivolous claim?

No. A weak claim is a claim that loses. A frivolous claim is one that is completely without merit in law and unsupportable by any reasonable argument to extend, modify or reverse existing law, or one brought primarily to delay, harass or maliciously injure, or one resting on material factual statements that are false. Losing is not sanctionable.

The line sits between losing and persisting. A novel theory is not frivolous. A theory the Appellate Division rejected last year, re-pleaded with a straight face, is closer. An allegation contradicted by a document the plaintiff signed is closer still, because it can implicate the false-statement branch.

The improper-purpose branch runs on its own track. A claim with colorable merit can still be sanctionable where the litigation is prosecuted primarily for improper purposes such as retribution or harassment, because subsection (c) is written in the disjunctive.

Case: Matter of Gordon v Marrone, 202 AD2d 104, 109-110 (2d Dept 1994), lv denied 84 NY2d 813 (1995).

Procedure protects the other side, and expect it to protect you. Under 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(d), an award may be made on motion in compliance with CPLR 2214 or 2215 or on the court’s own initiative, after a reasonable opportunity to be heard, the form of the hearing depending on the conduct and the circumstances. Under 130-1.2, the court may act only in a written decision setting out the conduct relied on, the reasons it was frivolous, and the reasons the amount is appropriate. The award is entered as a judgment.

Rule: 22 NYCRR 130-1.1(d); 22 NYCRR 130-1.2.

What are the first steps if you think the claim against you is frivolous?

The first steps in a Part 130 strategy are documentary and chronological, not rhetorical. Build the record that shows the conduct was baseless, that the plaintiff was told so, and that the plaintiff continued anyway. The motion is won by that sequence. Outrage is not evidence, and a sanctions motion filed on outrage alone is itself exposure.

I read the complaint against the documents it quotes before I read a single word of the plaintiff’s memorandum of law.

  • Collect the governing instruments first. The guaranty, the agreement sued on, the purchase order, the email the complaint paraphrases. Compare each to the allegation it supposedly supports.
  • Identify which branch of 130-1.1(c) you are invoking, in one sentence. If you cannot, you are describing a weak case, not a frivolous one.
  • Send a written demand to withdraw. Name the allegation, attach the refuting document, give a deadline. That creates the “brought to the attention of counsel or the party” fact.
  • Date everything. The rule weighs the time available to investigate and what happened after the defect became apparent. A timeline exhibit outworks argument.
  • Segregate your time records by the frivolous conduct. Costs are measured by the expenses that conduct caused, so the application must separate them from the general defense.
  • Decide on timing. Relief can be sought on motion or raised by the court itself, and a premature motion spends credibility you will want later.
  • Check the forum. Part 130 does not apply in town or village courts, in a small claims part, or in Family Court proceedings under article 3, 7 or 8.

Then set expectations. The best realistic outcome is reimbursement of the expenses and fees caused by the specific frivolous conduct, plus a sanction capped at $10,000 per occurrence paid to the state or the Lawyers’ Fund rather than to you. All of it is discretionary. That is meaningful, it is not your full defense cost, and it is no substitute for a fee clause in the contract.

Sued in New York?

Do not answer that complaint alone.

One call. A straight read on your case, your number, and exactly what happens over the next twenty days.

Call nowSee how we defend it

Joe Prencipe, Managing Partner of Prencipe International
Written by
Joe Prencipe
Managing Partner, Prencipe International

Before founding Prencipe International, Joe practiced at the top law firms in the world, including Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, Baker McKenzie, Morgan Lewis & Bockius, and served at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He has spent his career on high-stakes disputes and transactions for businesses that cannot afford to lose. When a New York business owner gets sued, he answers the same day and is on the docket within the week.

LinkedIn →

Share this:

You might also like

©2026 Prencipe International

PRENCIPEInternational
New York · Business Litigation Defense
★★★★★ 5.0 · 24 Google reviews
Call now
PRENCIPEInternationalCall now
©2026 Prencipe International
Business Litigation Defense · Nationwide