An earn-out is a contingent payment sale. Unless you elect out, it is reported on the installment method, which rations your basis across the earn-out period instead of returning it first. Sections 483 and 1274 then recast part of the deferred price as ordinary interest income, whether or not the purchase agreement mentions interest.
How are earn-out payments taxed when you sell your business?
Earn-out payments arrive in three slices for tax purposes: a return of your basis, gain on the sale, and interest. The installment method sets the first two slices and spreads basis over the life of the earn-out. The imputed interest rules set the third and tax it at ordinary rates. This analysis is stated as of October 2026.
Start with the label the regulations put on your deal. A contingent payment sale is one in which the total selling price cannot be determined by the close of the tax year of the sale. An earn-out does exactly that, and unless you elect otherwise it is reported on the installment method. You get that treatment by not opting out, and the opt-out has a deadline and a cost of its own.
It does not cover everything. Inventory, dealer dispositions, and publicly traded securities sit outside the method, and depreciation recapture is recognized in the year of sale. On an asset sale that is tax at closing on money you have not been paid.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 453(a), (b)(2), (i), (k); 26 C.F.R. 15a.453-1(c)(1), (d)(3)(i).
Why does the installment method spread your basis instead of returning it first?
Basis recovery in a contingent payment sale is rationed by regulation, not by the order the cash shows up. Temporary Regulation 15a.453-1(c) allocates basis against a stated maximum selling price, over a fixed payment period, or over fifteen years. Payments therefore carry taxable gain early, including payments that feel like a return of your own money.
| How the earn-out is written | How your basis comes back | What that means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Stated maximum selling price (a capped earn-out) | A gross profit ratio measured against the maximum | Most predictable. Each dollar carries a fixed fraction of gain |
| No maximum, but a fixed payment period | Equal annual parts over that period | Basis follows the stated term, not the cash |
| No maximum and no fixed period | Equal annual parts over fifteen years | The worst case. Gain is taxed early and basis comes back late |
| Substantial distortion relief | An alternative method, only on a private ruling request filed before the due date, with extensions, of the return for the year the first payment is received | Rare and discretionary. You must show the normal rule substantially and inappropriately defers basis and that yours recovers it twice as fast. Seldom proportionate on an owner-managed sale |
Law: 26 C.F.R. 15a.453-1(c)(2), (c)(3), (c)(4), (c)(7)(ii).
Under the second and third rules the allocation is mechanical, so a year whose payment is smaller than the basis assigned to it produces no gain and that basis carries forward. Only the gross profit ratio taxes a fixed fraction of every dollar. The lesson is short: cap the earn-out and give it a term.
Why is part of every earn-out payment taxed as interest?
Interest is imputed on deferred purchase price whether or not the purchase agreement mentions interest. Section 483 reaches a contract for the sale of property under which some payment is due more than one year after the sale and the contract lacks adequate stated interest. Adequate means a rate at least equal to the test rate, compounded at least annually.
It has limits: Section 483 does not apply where Section 1274 applies, or where the sales price is $3,000 or less.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 483(c), (d); 26 C.F.R. 1.483-1(a)(1), (c); 26 C.F.R. 1.483-2.
For the contingent part of the price the rules go further. Regulation 1.483-4 applies to a contract with contingent payments even where the contract does provide adequate stated interest. When a contingent payment is made, the interest piece is the excess of the payment over its present value, discounted back to the sale date at the test rate.
The regulation’s own examples show the size of the slice. A noncontingent $200,000 payment due five years out splits at a 5 percent test rate into $43,295 of interest and $156,705 of principal. A contingent payout worth $300,000 delivered three years after the sale carries $33,301 of unstated interest at a 4 percent test rate, roughly eleven percent of the payment taken out of sale proceeds and taxed at ordinary rates.
Law: 26 C.F.R. 1.483-4(a), (b) Examples 1 and 2; 26 C.F.R. 1.1275-4(c).
Section 1274 is the companion rule for debt instruments issued for property. Its exceptions include sales where total payments do not exceed $250,000, a statutory figure that is not indexed, and on a contingent price that exception applies only if the maximum cannot exceed it. Which section computes the interest turns on form: a bare right to a contingent payment is not a debt instrument, so Section 483 governs it. Either way, time value is ordinary interest at a test rate drawn from the applicable federal rates.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 1274(c)(3)(C); 26 C.F.R. 1.1274-1; 26 C.F.R. 1.483-4(b), Example 2.
The interest is not optional. The only thing you are negotiating is who pays for it.
Should the purchase agreement state interest on the earn-out?
Stating interest does not switch off the imputation rules for a contingent payment, because Regulation 1.483-4 applies even when a contract provides adequate stated interest. What stated interest changes is the cash. The buyer pays time value on top of the earn-out principal, instead of the regulations carving that value out of the number you already agreed to.
Run two versions. One: a $2,000,000 earn-out payable three years after closing, silent on interest. The regulations discount it back and tax the difference as ordinary income. Two: the same amount plus stated interest. You still report interest. You are also paid it.
I price an earn-out twice before I comment on the number: once as the draft purchase agreement states it, and once after the basis and interest rules take their cut.
- On the fixed deferred pieces, a seller note or a holdback, adequate stated interest at or above the test rate keeps the imputation rules from rewriting the payment. That cure does not extend to the contingent payments.
- Interest on a Section 483 contract is taken into account under your regular method of accounting. A cash method seller reports it when received, which matters when a payment slips across a year end.
Law: 26 C.F.R. 1.483-1(a)(2)(ii); 26 C.F.R. 1.483-4(a).
Can you elect out of the installment method and pay the tax at closing?
Electing out of the installment method is permitted under Section 453(d), at a price. The contingent right must be valued and taken into the amount realized in the year of sale. The election is due by the due date, including extensions, of the return for the year of the sale, and is revocable only with IRS consent.
A late election requires the IRS to be satisfied you had no tax avoidance purpose.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 453(d); 26 C.F.R. 15a.453-1(d)(1), (d)(3)(i), (d)(3)(ii).
Note the accidental version. Reporting an amount realized equal to the full selling price, including the face amount of the obligation, is treated as electing out. A preparer who was never told the earn-out existed can make that election for you.
Valuation is where electing out gets expensive. The regulation values a contingent obligation by disregarding transfer restrictions imposed by agreement or local law, and sets a floor: no less than the value of the property sold, less other consideration received.
Open transaction treatment is the exception sellers ask about and rarely get. In Burnet v. Logan the Supreme Court allowed a seller to recover basis first because the payments could not be valued. The regulation confines it to rare and extraordinary cases where value cannot reasonably be ascertained, and IRS Chief Counsel Advice 200004009 calls its reach after the 1980 legislation very limited.
Law: Burnet v. Logan, 283 U.S. 404 (1931); 26 C.F.R. 15a.453-1(d)(2)(iii); CCA 200004009.
Model the decision before the return is filed. An earn-out that later pays nothing still produced tax at closing.
When is an earn-out taxed as compensation instead of purchase price?
An earn-out payable only if you stay employed is exposed to recharacterization as compensation for services. Compensation is ordinary income, it carries employment tax on both sides within the usual wage base limits, and the buyer deducts it. Purchase price is capitalized by the buyer instead, which is why the label gets negotiated.
The rule is substance over form. A payment that is really consideration for your services is pay, whatever section of the agreement it sits in. Ask what has to happen for the money to be paid, and what has to happen for it to be lost.
I read the earn-out schedule and the employment agreement side by side, in that order, before I look at the headline price.
- Tie the payment to the business, not to you. The trigger should be a measurable company result, revenue or earnings over a defined period, computed under a stated accounting method.
- Press for survival on departure, and know where the line sits. Survival on death, disability, and termination without cause is an ordinary request. Full survival after a voluntary resignation is often refused where the buyer is paying for an owner-operator. Press anyway: an earn-out forfeited on resignation looks like pay for staying.
- Pay it pro rata to all sellers. Owners who never worked in the business should be paid on the same terms. Payment proportional to ownership is evidence that the money is price.
- Keep the documents separate. The earn-out belongs in the purchase agreement. The services belong in the employment agreement, with its own salary and bonus.
- Pay a real salary. A market wage for the work leaves less room to argue the earn-out is disguised pay for that same work.
Where the buyer will not release the employment condition, the fix is arithmetic, not labels. Shrink the earn-out and move the value into closing cash or a seller note carrying adequate stated interest.
If the only way to lose the earn-out is to quit, it is not purchase price. It is pay, and it will be taxed as pay.
What happens if the earn-out never pays?
A missed earn-out does not refund tax already paid on earlier payments. Under the contingent payment rules, basis allocated to a year that exceeds the payments received in that year is carried forward to the next year rather than deducted when no loss is allowed. Relief for unrecovered basis arrives later, in a different tax year.
There is one piece of built-in protection. A stated maximum selling price is treated as the selling price unless and until it is reduced, by the agreement, by amendment, or by a supervening event such as bankruptcy of the obligor. The gross profit ratio is then recomputed.
Law: 26 C.F.R. 15a.453-1(c)(2), (c)(3).
Ask your accountant what character that later loss takes and what it can offset. Tax paid in year one is not recovered in year one.
Section 453A imposes an interest charge on deferred tax where the sales price exceeds $150,000 and the face amount of installment obligations arising in the year and outstanding at year end exceeds $5,000,000. It runs only on the portion above that second figure. Both figures are statutory, not indexed. How the test applies to a partnership or S corporation seller is left to regulations the Treasury has not issued, so confirm it rather than assume it. Borrowing secured by an installment obligation is itself treated as a payment.
Law: 26 U.S.C. 453A(a), (b), (c)(4), (d), (e).
What should you do before you agree to the earn-out number?
Model the after-tax earn-out before signing the letter of intent, not after. The headline number is a gross figure that the installment and imputed interest rules will divide into basis, gain, and ordinary interest. Two deals with identical headline earn-outs can differ sharply in what reaches your account.
First steps:
- Send your accountant the earn-out schedule and ask which basis recovery rule applies: capped maximum, fixed period, or fifteen years.
- Ask which part of the price is recapture income, reportable in the year of sale whatever the payment schedule says.
- Ask for a projection with stated interest and without it, and ask for a cap and a stated term in the letter of intent, before the structure hardens.
- Check every trigger for an employment condition, and either remove it, narrow it, or price the earn-out as the pay it may become.
- Insist on two documents: a purchase agreement stating the earn-out, an employment agreement stating your salary.
- Decide the Section 453(d) question before the return for the year of sale is filed, and make sure your preparer knows the earn-out exists.
- Ask whether your deferred balance could reach the Section 453A thresholds.
Do this work while the earn-out is still a paragraph in a letter of intent. At that stage a cap, a term, a stated rate, and a survival clause are ordinary requests. After signing they are amendments.
Keep reading
The Seller’s LibraryYour installment sale defers less tax than you thinkThe Seller’s LibraryThe tax on your sale can come due before AprilThe DocketThe buyout price in your agreement usually holds.
Have a lawyer read it before you sign.
A sale is decided in a handful of documents you sign exactly once — the letter of intent, the working capital definition, the indemnity. There is no rush. When you want those read properly, we are here.

Before founding Prencipe International, Joe practiced at the top law firms in the world, including Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, Baker McKenzie, Morgan Lewis & Bockius, and served at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He has spent his career on high-stakes disputes and transactions for businesses that cannot afford to lose. He represents owners selling the company they spent a career building -- reading the letter of intent before it is signed, and the purchase agreement while there is still room to change it.
LinkedIn →
