A limitations period that has already expired can be brought back to life in New York. Outside consumer credit, two things do it: a writing you signed that acknowledges the debt, and a part payment made and accepted on an admitted debt. Mortgage foreclosure runs on a stricter rule. Send either one late and you may have restarted the clock.
Can a claim that is already time-barred be revived in New York?
Revival is real in New York, and it does not require a court order. General Obligations Law 17-101 makes an acknowledgment or promise contained in a writing signed by the party to be charged the only competent evidence of a new or continuing contract that takes an action out of the limitations bar.
The last sentence of the section matters as much as the first. Section 17-101 does not alter the effect of a payment of principal or interest. It does not codify the part payment rule either. It leaves that rule where the common law put it, which is why a payment can restart a period with no writing behind it.
Two limits sit on the face of the section. It reaches actions other than an action for the recovery of real property, which is why a foreclosure runs on a different track. And it yields to CPLR 214-i, which shuts revival down in consumer credit.
Law: N.Y. General Obligations Law 17-101.
What does General Obligations Law 17-101 require a writing to do?
Three things have to be true of the writing. Section 17-101 supplies the first: the writing must be signed by the party to be charged. The Court of Appeals supplies the other two: the writing must recognize an existing debt, and it must contain nothing inconsistent with an intention to pay that debt. Failing one is failing all three.
- Signed by the party to be charged. The creditor’s ledger entry is not a signed writing by you. A letter your accountant sent on your letterhead raises a different question: authority to sign.
- Recognizes an existing debt. The writing must point at the old obligation. A promise to pay a new sum, created by a new document, is not the same thing.
- Nothing inconsistent with an intention to pay. This is where defense lives. Reservation, dispute and protest language all cut against the inference the creditor needs.
Rule, then application. The Court of Appeals stated that standard in Lew Morris, a case about a one-year limitation period written into a demolition contract, and held the stipulation before it did not clear the bar. The document recognized no existing debt, and its “without prejudice” language cut against any intention to pay.
Case: Lew Morris Demolition Co. v. Board of Education, 40 N.Y.2d 516, 521 (1976).
Does an email or an electronic signature count as a signed writing?
An electronic signature may be used in place of a signature affixed by hand, and it carries the same validity and effect. State Technology Law 304(2) says so, unless some other law specifically provides otherwise. A countersigned PDF, an e-signature envelope and a typed name at the foot of an email are therefore live candidates, not safe ones.
Candidate is not the same as signature. The scheme turns on intent, because the mark must be executed or adopted with the intent to sign the record. An automatic footer appended by a mail server is a different fact from a name typed under the sentence confirming the balance.
You replied to a vendor at 11pm, confirmed the figure, and asked for thirty days. The analysis does not care that the keyboard was small.
I ask for the full signed-document set and the payment ledger on the account before I read the complaint.
Law: N.Y. State Technology Law 304(2).
Which documents most often create a written acknowledgment?
Three documents carry obvious revival risk in commercial disputes: a countersigned payment plan, a signed settlement term sheet, and a financial statement delivered to a lender. Each is signed. Each names a number. Whether any of them revives a stale claim depends on whether the document recognizes the old obligation rather than creating a new one.
The countersigned payment plan. A plan that recites the prior invoices, states a balance owed under the old supply agreement, and schedules installments does all three things the rule asks for. Installments are the opposite of language inconsistent with an intention to pay.
The signed settlement term sheet. A term sheet saying only that you will pay a sum to end a dispute may create a new obligation while saying nothing about the old one. Read the recitals. If they recite the original debt and call it due, the creditor’s work is done.
The financial statement given to a lender. A balance sheet listing the obligation as a liability is signed, delivered and specific. Whether it acknowledges anything turns on the same elements, and on which section of Article 17 governs. In foreclosure, a liability listing is not enough.
What did Petito v. Piffath decide about stipulations and revival?
Petito v. Piffath asked whether a stipulation settling a foreclosure action could be read as a written acknowledgment of the underlying mortgage debt, a promise to pay it, or a part payment of it, sufficient to revive an otherwise time-barred claim. The Court of Appeals held that the stale claim on the mortgage was not revived.
The reasoning is the useful part. A payment followed the stipulation, but it discharged an obligation arising only out of the stipulation itself. A document that creates and satisfies its own obligation does not acknowledge the old debt. The Court analyzed 17-101, 17-105(1) and 17-107(2)(b) and found revival under none.
Read Petito with its successor in hand. The Court of Appeals later explained that Petito did not decide which section of Article 17 governs a foreclosure action, because that question was not presented there. Petito tells you what a self-contained stipulation is not. It does not make 17-101 the foreclosure rule.
Signing a settlement does not automatically admit the old debt. It admits the settlement. The difference is the whole case.
Case: Petito v. Piffath, 85 N.Y.2d 1 (1994).
Is mortgage debt treated differently from ordinary contract debt?
An action to foreclose a mortgage runs on General Obligations Law 17-105, not on the general acknowledgment rule in 17-101. Section 17-105(1) requires an express promise to pay the mortgage debt, or a waiver of the expiration, made by the express terms of a writing signed by the party to be charged. Acknowledgment alone does not suffice.
Batavia Townhouses, Ltd. v. Council of Churches Housing Development Fund Co. decided that in 2022. The foreclosure claim was time-barred under CPLR 213(4), and the partnership’s financial statements and tax returns listed the mortgage as a liability. The Court of Appeals held that only 17-105(1) applies to such an action, that those documents were not express promises to pay, and that the period was neither tolled nor revived.
Part payment on a mortgage runs through its own section. Section 17-107 governs the effect of a payment on mortgage indebtedness, limits whose payment counts, and withholds effect from a payment accompanied by a writing disclaiming any intention to affect the time limited for foreclosure.
Note the limit. These sections govern the time to foreclose. An action on the note or a guaranty is a contract claim under 17-101.
Case: Batavia Townhouses, Ltd. v. Council of Churches Hous. Dev. Fund Co., 38 N.Y.3d 467 (2022).
Law: N.Y. General Obligations Law 17-105, 17-107; N.Y. CPLR 203(a), 213(4).
Can a payment restart the clock when nothing was signed?
Part payment can restart a limitations period with no signed writing anywhere. There must be payment of a portion of an admitted debt, made and accepted as such, with circumstances amounting to an absolute and unqualified acknowledgment that more is due, from which a promise to pay the remainder may be inferred. The standard is demanding.
- An admitted debt. If the amount was genuinely disputed when the payment went out, the predicate is missing.
- Made and accepted as such. Both sides must treat the money as a payment on that debt. A payment the creditor applied to another account is a different fact.
- Circumstances showing more is due. The payment has to carry an unqualified admission that a balance remains.
- A promise to pay the remainder may be inferred. The end of the chain, and it fails whenever the circumstances point the other way.
The doctrine is common law, preserved rather than created by 17-101, and courts apply it strictly. Lew Morris illustrates the failure. The money there moved under a stipulation calling it a partial settlement, not a payment of any character under the contract, and expressly without prejudice as to the balance. The claim stayed barred.
A payment made under protest is evidence of a fight, not of a promise. The words that travel with the check decide which one a court sees.
Case: Lew Morris Demolition Co. v. Board of Education, 40 N.Y.2d 516 (1976).
How do the revival routes compare?
The revival routes differ in what they demand, and the differences decide cases. A signed acknowledgment, an express promise on a mortgage, and a part payment each carry separate elements and separate defenses. The table sets them against each other so you can locate your own facts first.
| Route | What it requires | Authority | What defeats it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Written acknowledgment, ordinary contract debt | Signed writing recognizing an existing debt, with nothing inconsistent with an intention to pay | GOL 17-101; Lew Morris, 40 N.Y.2d at 521 | No signature; no reference to the old debt; reservation or dispute language |
| Written promise, action to foreclose a mortgage | Express promise to pay the mortgage debt, or waiver of expiration, by the express terms of a signed writing | GOL 17-105(1); Batavia Townhouses, 38 N.Y.3d 467 | Listing the mortgage as a liability, without an express promise to pay |
| Part payment, ordinary debt | Part of an admitted debt, paid and accepted as such, with circumstances showing more is due | Common law, left intact by GOL 17-101’s final sentence; Lew Morris, 40 N.Y.2d at 521 | Disputed sum; payment under protest; payment on a separate new obligation |
| Part payment, mortgage foreclosure | Payment on account of mortgage indebtedness, instalment or interest, by a qualifying person | GOL 17-107; Petito, 85 N.Y.2d 1 | A writing disclaiming an intention to affect the time limited for foreclosure |
| Consumer credit transaction | No revival route after expiration | CPLR 214-i | The statute itself: later payment or affirmation does not revive it |
Does any of this apply to consumer credit debt?
Consumer credit transactions sit outside the revival framework. CPLR 214-i, effective April 7, 2022, sets a three-year period for actions arising out of a consumer credit transaction where a purchaser, borrower or debtor is a defendant, and provides that once the applicable period expires, later payment, affirmation or other activity on the debt does not revive it.
Read the boundaries first. The section carves out CPLR 213-a, UCC Article 2 and General Business Law Article 36-B, and it turns on credit extended to an individual primarily for personal, family or household purposes. Its reach as to claims accruing before the effective date has been contested.
Commercial obligations, business guaranties and ordinary debts between companies remain governed by Article 17 and the case law above. Do not import the consumer rule into a business dispute.
Law: N.Y. CPLR 214-i.
What should you do tonight, before you rely on the statute of limitations?
The first move is evidentiary, not legal. Before anyone pleads a time bar, the written and payment history on the account has to be collected and dated, because revival turns on documents the defendant created. A limitations defense asserted without that review can die on a single forgotten email.
- Stop signing. Sign nothing that states a balance, confirms a figure or proposes a schedule. Not a payment plan, not a term sheet, not an email.
- Pull every payment. Bank records, ACH history, check images, and the creditor’s statements showing how each payment was applied. The last payment date often decides the question.
- Pull every signed writing. Amendments, forbearance letters, estoppel certificates, guaranties, lender financial statements, tax returns and signed emails. Search your sent folder by the creditor’s domain, not by subject line.
- Read the language that traveled with the money. “Without prejudice,” “under protest,” “partial settlement” and “disputed” are not decoration. Those words did work when written, and can work again.
- Identify the debt type. Foreclosure runs through 17-105 and 17-107. Consumer credit runs through CPLR 214-i. Everything else, including the note and the guaranty, runs through 17-101.
- Date the accrual, then date every later act. The period runs from accrual, which for a contract claim is the breach, not the demand letter. Then timeline every signature and payment after it.
I build that timeline before I take a position on the limitations defense, and I refuse to assume a date is clean until the ledger and the signature file both confirm it.
A limitations defense is one of the strongest things a defendant holds, and the easiest to give away without noticing. You give it away with a signature or a check. Handle both as pleadings.
Keep reading
The DocketSued on a promissory note in New York.The DocketYour expired claim can still shrink theirs.The Seller’s LibraryYou can agree to sell your company by email by accident
Do not answer that complaint alone.
One call. A straight read on your case, your number, and exactly what happens over the next twenty days.

Before founding Prencipe International, Joe practiced at the top law firms in the world, including Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, Baker McKenzie, Morgan Lewis & Bockius, and served at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He has spent his career on high-stakes disputes and transactions for businesses that cannot afford to lose. When a New York business owner gets sued, he answers the same day and is on the docket within the week.
LinkedIn →
